Someone is burning Deer Trail, Colorado.
Beautiful Francesca Starry wants the love of only one man, but he keeps rejecting her. When the new-in-town ranch hand Mingo wants to court her, she agrees to do so in secret, despite her guilt in hiding him from her family. Then she sees the man lighting her town on fire. The danger rises, and she realizes there is only one man she truly trusts. But after rejecting her for so long, will he be able to be there for her now?
Francesca’s sister, Charity, has come so far since joining the Starry family. But as she falls in love with the new, cute deputy, Will her past hold her back? Can she really trust him?
The Starry sisters are in danger, and not just with their hearts. Will the Starry sisters trust their own hearts, or will they trust their heavenly Father’s will? Which one will lead to their happiness?